This is no co-incidence. This is the unwritten law in TN cricket these days. TN selectors dont watch matches played by non India Cements teams in the first division. 21 year old left arm spinner M Siddharth, who first played as
an 11 year old in the TNCA league in the team (Sir MCTM Old Boys) that I
captained (for a decade) has finally found a place in the TN team for the interstate one day
tournament that will start later this month, this after many years of strong
performances in the first division league and the interstate age group tournaments But unfortunately there is a twisted angle to his
selection at this point and the reason why TN has fared so badly all these years.
Mentoring under V Suresh ( Former SBI) for a decade
His cricketing story began as a 7 year old when he joined V Suresh's Academy at Meenakshi College, Kodambakkam. The Former SBI player's cricket academy is easily one of the best in the city. Suresh knows the name of every single player in his academy. He is personally present every single day talking to his wards, both of these are credits that most academies/coaches in the city cannot boast.
It was Suresh who stood with Siddharth during the first decade of his cricket seeing him through the U14, U16 and U19 phases helping him both with his left arm spin as well as the attitude that differentiates Siddharth in the cricketing circles today. It was Suresh who mentored Siddharth throughout this entire foundation phase of his career. If Siddharth is still down to earth as a human being, a lot of the credit goes to Suresh for his mentoring. Till very recently, Siddharth would visit Suresh on the eve of every match to take his 'Acharya's' blessing, yet another feature that very few youngsters follow today. His move this year to India Cements too had the blessings of Suresh.
Strong Performances
Siddharth picked up 22 wickets in 6 matches years ago
playing for IOB in the first division. He has since figured in the state team
in age group cricket – U16, U19 and U23 and also played for South Zone U19.
In 2017-18, he was the leading wicket taker in the VAP one day tournament that takes place between the first division teams. In the
same season, he was 2nd in the bowling rankings taking 52 wickets in
the first division league.
Aged 19, with these consistent performances behind him - 2nd among the bowlers in the Palayampatti shield and the top wicket taker in the one day league, he did not figure in the TN squad for any of the tournaments – Ranji Trophy, Vijay Hazare or the T20 tournament (Syed Mushtaq Ali).
Aged 19, with these consistent performances behind him - 2nd among the bowlers in the Palayampatti shield and the top wicket taker in the one day league, he did not figure in the TN squad for any of the tournaments – Ranji Trophy, Vijay Hazare or the T20 tournament (Syed Mushtaq Ali).
Last season, he picked up 43 wickets in the first division
league, that’s a whopping 95wickets in two league seasons.
Not considered despite extraordinary showing
The reason for his exclusion… And here comes the twist that
most youngsters in TN cricket have struggled to come to terms with. He was playing for Alwarpet, a team run by Chemplast. As has
been known to most in the Chennai cricketing circles, it is quite difficult for
upcoming cricketers to find their name in the TN squad unless they belong to
any of the teams run by India Cements. It has almost become an unwritten law in
TN cricket - such is state of affairs of the powers that be who have been
running cricket over the last decade or two.
Interestingly in the 3 years preceding that, Siddharth had
taken 22, 22 and 31wickets in the first division league. Last year, in the U23 state matches, he took close to 30
wickets. Many years ago, when he was in the U16 age group, he picked
up over 30 wickets for TN and ranked in the top 3 in the wicket takers list
across the country (Remember another upcoming left arm spinner S Sriram having
done that many decades ago in the U13 and U15 tournaments at that time). To date Siddharth has close to 200 wickets in the first division
across formats.
Youngsters standing firm till their heart is broken
Another youngster who is standing firm for the moment is
left handed batsman Vishal Vaidya who continues to play for Alwarpet. He has scored lot of runs for Alwarpet and in the U19 and U23 levels. In the recent past, players (from non India
Cements teams) like Thalaivan Sargunan (MRF) - he scored tons of runs at his peak, fast bowler Rohith Ramalingam ( he has performed well in the TNPL and in the VAP tourney) and AC Prathiban who has been picking up wickets consistently almost every season have all been ignored. There are many more such talented players for whom there seems to be no light playing for the non Indian Cements teams.
Much like Vishal Vaidya, Siddharth too remained firm till
this year that he would not move out of Alwarpet. Why would anyone move out of
a team after picking up well over 100 wickets for them in two seasons and
having figured in the top of the league championship. Same for Vishal Vaidya
too. If he is batting in the top 4 for his team and getting ample
opportunities to make a mark and if he is scoring centuries and his team is
making it to the knock outs (and if he is paid well too) what reason would such
a youngster have to move to another team other than this ugly unwritten rule in
TN cricket of ‘play for India Cements’ team and you will make it to the next
big league.
It is truly commendable that at 22, Vishal Vaidya has taken a philosophical stance of sticking to a team where he has made runs and is continuing with the hope that merit would take him to the top. Siddharth too was on the same path until the below communication happened a few months back.
It is truly commendable that at 22, Vishal Vaidya has taken a philosophical stance of sticking to a team where he has made runs and is continuing with the hope that merit would take him to the top. Siddharth too was on the same path until the below communication happened a few months back.
One of the top cricketing officials of India Cements
met Siddharth personally ahead of this new season and got him to sign up for
the team (he moved from Alwarpet to Grand Slam this new league season). And
the outcome is there for all to see within a matter of three months. He has just been included in the 14 man TN squad for the Vijay
Hazare tournament.
It is unlikely he would have made the squad had
he continued with Alwarpet going by the past record of the selectors (they dont watch these league matches).
Is this the direction India Cements' bosses want Cricket to go in Tamil Nadu. Is this
the message they want to give upcoming youngsters. Play for IC if you want to get
into the TN squad. Centuries and wickets wont matter if you keep playing club cricket for other teams. Many have
experienced this over the last decade and it has only increased with time (India Cements runs 14 league teams in the
TNCA league). It is said that selectors are mute spectators at meetings with the powers that be having a strong say in the selection.
Top Officials of India Cements have played top notch cricket
in the local league in their times. It is now time for them to move away from
this short sighted self driven approach. This attitude was also a reason for
the fall from the top at the national level when they held the powers not so
long ago. If they do not recognize the wrongs that are happening in TN cricket
and do not provide a fair deal to talented and performing youngsters, they will pay a
price in the not too distant future.
A coach of many years of one of the leading non India
Cements teams in the first division said that no selector has had a look at his
team in the last three years in any of the first division matches or VAP one
day tournament. The last time he says a selector watched their team play was
when Kalli (B Kalyanasundaram) visited their ground and watched a match many
years ago. Is this the way India Cements wants to run cricket in Tamil Nadu.
Selectors would sit in the comforts of the TNCA and select a team dominated by
players from the India Cements.
This is a sad tale and one hopes that the top officials will
take remedial action this season and select players on merit irrespective of
the clubs they play for. These officials have had their time for far too long. It is now
time for some Fair Play in TN cricket
My god. ....bold and beautiful. ..u have torn everyone apart. ...really bold truth
ReplyDelete����������.. Good & Strong Points..
ReplyDeleteTN cricket is going to dogs.Now TNPL scandal and no elections will lead to us being isolated in BCCI.As it is none of the teams of TN at any level is doing well due to literal no administration.The ruling team is interested only in IPL(CSK) and TNPL
ReplyDeleteBrilliant write-up ������������
ReplyDeleteசரியான சாட்டையடி ��������
It is not only in TN it all over India.Please go through who all travelled to South Africa for an IPL tournament how and why?.The situation not only for cricketer it also for the TNCA officials,coaches, mangers etc etc.
ReplyDeleteI don't think anything is going to change event after the implementation of Lodha recommendations. The same people will be in power through their proxies. The reason is that entire TNCA is controlled by the votes of the 150 or so league clubs which are all mostly loyal to the current establishment due to various reasons. There are only 31 districts and hence they don't have much voice when it comes to voting.
ReplyDeleteAs far as I understand, Lodha report did not recommend vote for league clubs. It recommended votes only for district associations in a state. But it looks like this has been ignored and most state associations are giving votes to their league clubs. For example, Tamil Nadu Cricket Association (TNCA) has 150 or so league clubs (all based in Chennai as league matches happen in Chennai) and 31 district associations. So pretty much everything is controlled by the clubs' votes. District association does not have much voice. Lodha report specifically wanted this unfairness to stop. No one in the CoA seems to be looking into this.
If the voting does not change I do not expect any change in TNCA.
Fantastic piece sir. Very bold and need of the hour...
ReplyDeleteExcellent. The reality laid bare
ReplyDeletePrabhu .. don’t know your intention behind this article .. but it sort of takes credit away from a well deserved selection ..
ReplyDeleteDear Prabhu,
ReplyDeleteThis is very brave, bordering suicidal in terms of your access to players, past & present and the administrators who feature regularly in your articles :)
Nothing is going to change, it simply wouldn't till the whole, "You scratch my back and I scratch yours" policy is rooted out of Indian cricket from top to bottom.
The one problem I have with such articles is when you romanticise a youngster who hasn't got a call because he doesn't play for a particular team, you ought to remember that this romanticism of yours could be perceived as the boy's arrogance by the powers that be and probably shut whatever little of the door was open for him.